Every buyers agent you speak to will tell you they're on your side. So how would you actually know?
When you're making a big move, who you trust matters as much as what you buy. At the top end of Sydney, a lot of homes sell off market, and they sell quietly. You rely on the one person you hire to find those homes and help you judge them. So picking that person is the first decision, and everything else hangs off it.
These are the five questions I'd ask any buyers agent before you sign, in the order I'd ask them. A good buyers agent will answer every one of them straight. I answered all five myself on episode 90 of Buy Your Side, so you can hold me to the same test.
1. Are you licensed in NSW, for how long, and can I check it?
In NSW, a buyers agent must hold either a real estate agent's licence, or a certificate of registration and work under the direction of a licensed agent. You can check any licence yourself on Verify NSW, the NSW Government's public register, or by calling NSW Fair Trading on 13 32 20.
Look at the history, not just the class. A Class 1 licence normally takes about three years to reach in NSW: at least a year as an assistant agent, then at least two years on a Class 2, with supervised work along the way. There's a shortcut around it through Queensland and mutual recognition. So if the history looks short, ask how they got their Class 1.
That supervised time matters. Getting a licence is a small part of being a good buyers agent. The rest is lived experience: searches, negotiations and auctions, learnt under someone experienced before you lead them yourself. You don't want your buyers agent practising their skills on your search, your money and your purchase.
My answer: I've been a buyers agent since 2008. I hold a NSW Class 1 licence, and so does every buyers agent on our team.
I started in Queensland. In NSW, I first held a certificate of registration in 2010, working under licensed agents, and was granted my own buyers agent licence in 2017. It became a Class 1 licence when NSW changed its licence categories in 2020. No shortcuts.
2. Is your fee tied to the price I pay?
If a buyers agent charges a percentage, the more you spend, the more they earn. That's a conflict of interest, and it sits right where it matters most: when they're negotiating the price for you. How hard would anyone push on price if it left less in their own pocket?
My answer: No. Find & Buy is a flat fee, quoted on how complex your search is, never on the price you pay. It should be that straightforward.
3. Does anyone else pay you in this deal?
Referral money can run both ways, so ask about both. Do they receive referral fees, and do they pay them?
A very common arrangement is a selling agent recommending a buyers agent. In my experience, the selling agent can be paid 20 to 30% of the fee you pay that buyers agent. So if someone speaks very highly of a buyers agent, be mindful there may be money behind it.
In NSW, referral arrangements go on a form called the Section 47. It must be given to you when the agent refers you to anyone, and before you sign a contract to buy. The form itself says if you get it afterwards, don't sign it. I'd ask to see it before you sign up, because if it first turns up when you're about to buy your dream home, who's getting paid will be the last thing on your mind.
My answer: I don't accept or pay referral fees. Our Section 47 shows Nil, and you sign it on the day you sign up with us. Anyone we recommend, from cleaners and painters to architects, is on our list on merit. Our team and our past clients have vetted them, and we keep asking for feedback so the standard stays high.
4. Will you act for anyone else who could bid on the same home?
Even with clean money, there's one more conflict, and it's easy to forget. If two of an agent's clients want the same home, one of them misses out. You won't always know which one is you.
If a buyers agent takes on several clients with the same brief, ask yourself where they're compromising.
My answer: No. We don't take on clients with competing briefs. If yours would compete with a client we're already working for, we'll put you on our waitlist until they've bought. There's only a limited amount of good stock for sale, whether it's an $800K unit or a $10 million house, and I don't want to play favourites. I want to sleep at night.
5. How many buyers are you working for right now?
Most people assume they'll be the only one. But an agent's attention only stretches so far, and they're running a business.
My answer: Nobody on our team looks after more than four clients at a time, and I take on fewer than that, because I also run the podcast and Better Home Buying. Every big decision gets a second experienced set of eyes, and I give the final sign-off, so we're always stress testing each other's work. A lot of our clients are new to Sydney or going through a big life change. That takes time, and it deserves it.
How should you use these five questions?
Ask all five, in this order, at the first meeting. Better still, check their licence on Verify NSW before you meet. In my view, a buyers agent shouldn't be working on their own until they've had at least five years buying for clients, and earned their Class 1 the way NSW intends. If they haven't, I'd pass.
Then listen to how they answer. These are short questions with short answers. If you get a story instead of a clear yes or no, that tells you something too.
Ask every buyers agent you speak to the same five, so you're comparing apples with apples:
Are you licensed in NSW, for how long, and can I check it?
Is your fee tied to the price I pay?
Does anyone else pay you in this deal, or do you pay anyone?
Will you act for anyone else who could bid on the same home?
How many buyers are you working for right now?
For more on choosing a buyers agent, listen to Buy Your Side 60, How to Choose a Buyers Agent? Ask If You'll Be One of Many or One of One, or read How to choose a trustworthy buyers agent.
Frequently asked questions
How do I check if a buyers agent is licensed in NSW?
Anyone can check a licence on Verify NSW or with NSW Fair Trading on 13 32 20. The normal path to a Class 1 licence in NSW takes about three years, so if their history looks really short, ask how they got their Class 1.
Should a buyers agent's fee be a percentage of the price?
A percentage fee means the more you spend, the more the buyers agent earns. That's a conflict of interest, right when they're negotiating for you. Michelle May Buyers Agents charges a flat fee: Find & Buy is quoted on how complex your search is, never on the price you pay.
What is a Section 47 form?
In NSW, a buyers agent's referral arrangements go on a form called the Section 47. It must be given to you when the agent refers you to anyone, and before you sign a contract to buy. Ask to see it before you sign up. Michelle May doesn't accept or pay referral fees, so her Section 47 shows Nil.
Can a buyers agent work for two buyers chasing the same home?
If two of an agent's clients want the same home, one of them misses out, and you won't always know which one is you. Michelle May Buyers Agents doesn't take on competing briefs. If yours would compete with a current client, you go on the waitlist until they've bought.
How many buyers should my buyers agent be working for?
Most people assume they'll be the only one, but an agent's attention only stretches so far, so ask. Nobody on the Michelle May Buyers Agents team looks after more than four clients at a time, and every big decision gets a second experienced set of eyes.
Want someone in your corner?
If you're weighing up a big move in the Inner West or the Eastern Suburbs, the next step is a conversation, not a sales pitch. Book a free 20-minute call with me.
This is general information, not personal advice. Talk to your own broker, solicitor or conveyancer about your situation.
Michelle May has been a buyers agent since 2008. Independent and Sydney-based, she hosts the Buy Your Side podcast and created Better Home Buying.

